“Imagine all the people
Living life in peace
Lending to and borrowing from each other freely
Oooh-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo
You may say that we’re dreamers
But we know how greedy financial institutions are
We hope some day you’ll join us
In a world of better APR”
That’s Zopa’s message to those visitors who deem themselves idealists. They have one for you too, whether you are a worrier, con-artist, control freak, or someone who thinks finance is boring.
Zopa is anything but boring. It is taking on the most powerful force in human society - economic power.
In case you haven’t yet read about Zopa, it is most vividly described as “an eBay for money.” In other words, it is a marketplace where private lenders and private borrowers meet, find a “zone of possible agreement” (zopa), and consummate the transaction. Members of Zopa lend and borrow within the network. No banks, no middlemen.
Even if they won’t admit it, it has financial institutions a little nervous. The first sign: they are coming out with strong warnings to consumers to be very afraid.
The founders of Zopa began with the philosophy that 99% of people are trustworthy, but Zopa isn’t slack. Borrowers are rated by the same credit agencies all financial institutions use, and must produce 6 different forms of ID. Lenders set interest rates themselves, and Zopa gets a 1% fee up front from the borrowers. All lending is across groups of at least 50, so no one lender assumes all the risk for any loan. Maximum exposure for a lender is 200 British pounds. All contracts are legally binding, and if a borrower defaults, collection agencies will come calling.
It isn’t the concept of community lending that is fascinating. After all, family and friends have been lending and borrowing before there was money. No. Zopa signals far more significant shifts.
Most obvious and far reaching is the potential of putting finances into the hands of “consumers” rather than institutions. Conceivably, Zopa, and the inevitable look-alikes, will erode the most powerful force in society – the control of the money supply. If you think the Internet has shifted information power to the people, think about the dramatic change in dynamics when consumers hold significant control over the money supply.
“Zopa is an idea, not a company,” say founders Richard Duvall and James Alexander. Zopa members are, according to Duvall and Alexander, excited about the idea of being able to lend to specific groups of people – teachers or nurses that couldn’t afford conventional lending for a house, or perhaps to a community housing development, or other specific need as seen as by the members of the Zopa network. Now, how will that shift political systems and community systems?
Secondarily, this type of network may drive new “online reputation” systems. Today, we rank sellers on eBay, music, books, blog and web site popularity. Will something like Zopa also move our reputations into a far more public space? For example, right now, if you default on your Zopa loan, Zopa refers you to a collection agency, and your credit report gets dinged, but that ding only shows up on private rating systems – credit reporting databases. Will this bring about new types of “public reputations” within networks, and along with it new degrees of “self-regulation” and accountability? It isn’t a stretch to see a borrower ranking feature crop up, similar to eBay’s seller rating.
Without doubt, Zopa will leapfrog over our stagnant 15th century banking system in a very short period of time. Performance is the primary ingredient, and Zopa will have to deliver it, but this holds all the elements of innovation that could rock the foundations of long-standing institutions and power-bases. Zopa could be the tip of an iceberg as we increasingly operate in and depend upon social networks.
Look deeply.
